1 on 1 Tutoring vs Group Class: Which is Best for Your Child?

Comparison of 1-on-1 tutoring and group classes: one-on-one gives all attention to one student at their own pace in a private setting at a higher cost; group classes share attention, set the pace for the group, are more social and cost less per child.

Short answer: Choose 1-on-1 tutoring if your child needs personalized pacing, close feedback and flexible scheduling. Choose a group class if your child is social, motivated by peers and you want a lower price per child. Both work: research summarized by the EEF links small-group tutoring to about four months of extra progress and one-to-one to about five.

If you’re looking into extracurricular tutoring for your child, there are generally two options: 1-on-1 tutoring or group tutoring classes. Both tutoring styles are proven to help address the learning needs of students, even to the extent of advancing them four to five months ahead in progress.

Numbers like these suggest that the individual attention and care that students get in either tutoring setting are key in helping them build crucial learning skills and get ahead.

So, which one do you choose? Both styles of private tutoring have their own advantages, so let’s take a look at some factors that can help you make a choice.

Key points

  • Both styles work: Small-group and one-to-one tutoring both add months of learning progress.
  • 1-on-1 is personal: The tutor focuses on one student and adapts methods and pace.
  • Groups are social: Peers bring collaboration, games and a little friendly competition.
  • Level matters in groups: Group tutoring works best when students are at about the same level.
  • Flexible scheduling: One student and one tutor makes rescheduling easier, especially online.
  • Groups cost less: Families split the cost, so the price per child is lower.

What is 1-on-1 tutoring?

The concept of one-on-one tutoring is considered to be one of the oldest teaching methods still in use.

Research shows that tutoring, especially multiple sessions a week, can help students recover and catch up to where they need to be, no matter the subject. However, even just one session a week can help your child boost their skills and learning.

One reason for this is that a 1-on-1 tutor is able to put all of their attention and focus on just one student. Classroom teachers do their best to adapt to different learning styles and meet each student’s needs, but classroom resources today are stretched to the max, and one teacher can only do so much in a classroom full of students.

A personal tutor can give personalized attention to their student while testing out different methodologies to see what works best. Because of this personalized approach, private tutoring sessions give the student and tutor time to bond and cultivate a friendly, trusting relationship.

How do group tutoring classes work?

Group tutoring can also be an effective tool in helping your child make academic progress. The number of students in the group varies and can depend on the tutor’s preferences or the needs of the students in the group.

Something interesting about this setup is that it can create a classroom atmosphere, similar to a school setting, but more relaxed and much more personalized. That’s the big advantage here when it comes to classroom vs. tutoring learning.

For this to work, the students should be at or around the same level. This ensures that the tutor can spend an equal amount of time with each student, but can address concepts and methodologies to everyone at once.

Group tutoring can take place at home or in a tutoring center, but online tutoring services are also a popular option. As you can imagine, small group tutoring is much more social than 1-on-1 personalized learning. This can encourage peer learning, stimulate a little healthy competition, and provide the opportunity for learners to try games or group activities.

What are the benefits of 1-on-1 tutoring?

One-on-one tutoring has several benefits for learners. As mentioned, this style of tutoring is highly personalized and adapted to the student’s needs and abilities. These factors are proven to bump up grades and help kids meet their individual learning goals.

  • Close assessment and feedback: Because of the close attention, tutors can closely assess their student’s progress while providing effective feedback and correction along the way.
  • The right pace: This assessment allows the tutor to adjust the pace to the student’s needs, either slowing down to reinforce difficult concepts or speeding up to find more challenging material.
  • A fit for specific needs: This style of tutoring is good for students who have specific learning preferences or those who are looking to move at their own pace.
  • Flexible scheduling: Since there is just one student and one teacher, scheduling can typically be quite flexible, especially when you consider online tutoring as an option.

Tutors and students generally agree on a schedule when they start arranging tutoring sessions, but it’s usually nice for both parties to have a little bit of flexibility in case things pop up and the sessions need to be rearranged.

Tutor tip: In a 1-on-1 session, the tutor can only adjust to what they can see. Have your child bring recent homework, quizzes and the problems they got stuck on, so the session targets the real gaps.

Want lessons built around your child alone?

Our one-on-one online tutors adapt every session to your child’s pace and learning style in math and physics, with scheduling that bends when life gets busy.

Book a risk-free first lesson →

Or explore our online tutoring services.

What are the advantages of group classes?

For learners who are social butterflies, group types of tutoring may be more their speed. More reserved kids might find that having peers to work with can give them a boost in confidence and motivation.

  • Less pressure: There is less pressure to finish tasks independently.
  • Social skills: Students have the opportunity to collaborate and support each other during the learning process, which can help children build their peer socialization skills.
  • More dynamic activities: Students can form teams, pairs, or small groups to have competitions, make presentations, or work on collaborative activities that inspire learning, fun, and even a little friendly competition.
  • Lower cost: Group classes tend to be less expensive for parents since they can split the cost, resulting in a lower price per child.

While 1-on-1 tutors certainly have the option to play games or design dynamic activities for their students, there is more possibility to put these things in action in a group setting. Working in this way can help students engage more in their learning, and they can even help others around them. For more on learning from classmates, see how peer tutoring compares to other tutoring methods.

How do 1-on-1 tutoring and group classes compare?

1-on-1 tutoringGroup class
AttentionAll of the tutor’s focus on one studentShared among students at a similar level
PaceAdjusted to the student, faster or slowerSet for the group
Social settingPrivate, trusting tutor relationshipPeer learning, teamwork, friendly competition
SchedulingFlexible, easy to rearrangeFixed to suit the group
Cost per childHigherLower, since families split the cost
Best forSpecific needs, own pace, targeted goalsSocial learners who are motivated by peers

How do you choose the right tutoring option for your child?

Now that you know a little about each style of tutoring, it’s time to decide what works best for your child. Work through these factors:

  1. Consider learning style and personality. Does your child thrive with personal attention, or come alive around peers?
  2. Define the learning goals. Goals decide whether your child would benefit most from personalized attention or a social atmosphere.
  3. Look at cost. Compare the price of both tutoring options for your family.

Tutor tip: If your child is behind in a specific topic or has a big test coming up, start 1-on-1 to close the gap quickly. A group class can work well later for steady practice and motivation.

Alexander Tutoring has a team of professional online tutors who specialize in delivering high-impact 1-on-1 sessions in math and physics. Each tutor adapts their lessons to their students’ needs, style, and abilities, which allows students to get results and hit their learning goals. Not sure tutoring is needed yet? Here are 5 signs your child needs a math tutor, and here is what tutoring looks like for students with learning disabilities.

Tutor-written guide · PDF

Tips for Performing Well During STEM Exams

The game plan our tutors give students before a big math or science test. Enter your name and email and the guide opens right away.

  • The night-before routine that beats cramming
  • A first-five-minutes plan: formula dump, read-through, quick wins
  • Halfway and 10-minute checkpoints so time never runs out
  • Calm-down steps for test anxiety you can use mid-exam
Test Anxiety Lead Magnet

Frequently asked questions

Is 1-on-1 tutoring better than group tutoring?

Neither is better for every child. One-on-one tutoring offers personalized pacing, close feedback and flexible scheduling, while group tutoring offers peer collaboration, more dynamic activities and a lower price per child.

How much progress can tutoring add?

The Education Endowment Foundation’s toolkit links small-group tutoring to about four months of additional progress and one-to-one tutoring to about five months.

How many tutoring sessions a week does my child need?

Research shows tutoring several times a week helps students catch up fastest, but even one session a week can help a child boost their skills and learning.

When does group tutoring work best?

Group tutoring works best when the students are at or around the same level, so the tutor can teach concepts to everyone at once and still give each student a fair share of time.

Why is group tutoring cheaper?

Families in a group class split the cost of the tutor’s time, so the price per child is lower than for one-on-one tutoring.

Give your child a tutor who teaches just them

Our tutors are working mathematicians, scientists and engineers who teach one-on-one, online. Your first lesson is risk-free. Explore online tutoring services or meet our tutors.

Get in touch → We respond within 30 minutes.

Author

  • Sean alexander

    Sean Alexander holds a B.S. in Physics from UC Santa Barbara and an M.S. in Physics from San Francisco State University. He has taught math, physics and astronomy at every level since 2004 — from advanced physics at Stanford to a high school serving students with severe learning differences, including ADHD, dyscalculia and autism. He founded Alexander Tutoring in 2009 to reveal the deep connections between math and nature to as many students as possible. Connect with Sean on LinkedIn.

    View all posts
Share this article with a friend